I can’t go along with my colleagues who regard Alexander Payne’s entertaining but familiar comedy as one of 2004’s best movies: it lacks the insolence of his Election and the freshness of his work with Kathy Bates in About Schmidt. A depressive, divorced unpublished novelist (American Splendor‘s Paul Giamatti) and a cheerful, horny former TV star (Thomas Haden Church) who’s about to be married embark on a tour of the California wine country that includes sexual adventures. The performances of both leads (especially Church), Virginia Madsen, and Sandra Oh are effective, and Payne does know how to capture two kinds of male menopause. But I can’t say he ever surprised me.


Reader Recommends: FILM & TV

Our critics review the best on the big and small screens and in the media.

Review: The Brutalist

The Brutalist is a massive American epic that damns the ground we stand on.

Review: Nickel Boys

Nickel Boys, an adaptation of Colson Whitehead’s novel, is a cinematic revolution.

Review: The Fire Inside

The Fire Inside is a dynamic and artistic telling of the story of real-life boxing legend Claressa “T-Rex” Shields.

Review: Skeleton Crew

Skeleton Crew provides a new angle on the Star Wars cinematic universe—one that puts childhood adventure front and center.